Online dating, what’s next?

by David Evans on March 25, 2005 · 4 comments

in Dating Sites

Online Dating Insider delivers cutting-edge insight and commentary on all aspects of the online dating industry. Topics include industry news, site reviews, emerging trends, analysis of dating site features, discussion about safety safety, finance and other issues important to the online dating market. Don't miss our Startups directory, useful to anyone running dating or social networking sites. Subscribe to the RSS feed (you can subscribe via email as well). Your comments and suggestions for stories are welcomed.
We offer consulting services to dating sites and social networks as well.

Lately I’ve had several discussions with people about the future of the dating industry. Niche portals, open profiles, customer acquisition costs, personality testing, conversion rates (thanks bob!), enhanced search, blogs and advertising seem to be the topics that pop up most frequently. I’ll tackle a few topics now and base additional posts on feedback from you loyal readers.

Niche Portals
The dating site becomes a branded niche portal, in a way that the large date warehouses never will. We’re back to the SpringStreet model, but it’s been a few years and the industry has has time to learn from SpringStreet’s mistakes and improve on the model of a shared database. Brand the interface however you want, NASCAR, NFL, Starbucks, etc. Provide members with great customer service and an experience they can’t get anywhere else. When is the last time you heard two people at a bar say how fantastic their online dating site is?

Lower customer acquisition costs
There is much discuss about rising customer acquisition costs ($40!). What if sites made it easier for people to come and go? Would more people leave existing sites for other sites, thinning the crowd of sites out there that are barely hanging on? Or with the right marketing, would more people try online dating, raising up the entire industry?

Towards a single profile
I am tired of maintaining multiple profiles on scores of dating sites. I had 20 at one point, now I’m down to a handful. In my mind, more than one is too much. I have a master document with all my profile text on all the services. It’s something like 25 pages long. A total nightmare to maintain. I love the idea of a single profile. Easy to maintain, portable and upgradable. Try doing that with your current dating profiles. Never happen. Sooner or later, people will get sick of filling out and maintaining all these profiles.

Large date warehouses like Match and Yahoo! don’t want to talk about “open profiles” which can be shared across several sites. Why make it easy for the customer to leave? The value becomes apparent when looking at smaller dating sites.

An initial step towards a single profile is a FOAF (friend of a friend) file. A FOAF file is human-readable XML file containing personal as well as professional information. For example, my FOAF file is located at http://www.socialpeople.com/foaf/foaf.rdf. Most web browsers are unable to read the file unless the server has been configured to display the information so you can read it. FoaF Explorer is a discovery service that searches FOAF files of your friends. XFN (XHTML Friends Network and FOAF together provide the building blocks for remarkable services that provide new contexts, features and services that will make look today’s dating sites look like stone tablets.

Think of all the different profile a user may have:
personal ads
business networking
social networking
banking
medical
e-commerce

What if there was a central repository where you could manage your profiles? The service would serve up profiles based on the context of the interaction. In my mind, a new player is going to have to enter the space, offering profile management, reputation management, taxonomies for tagging entities to indicate relationships (friend of, works for, dates, knows, belongs to) and other essential services and security infrastructure to support a working system based on contextually relevant profiles.

Mark Eisenstadt writes more on the subject.

{ 4 comments }

YoNo Gravatar 03.25.05 at 11:52 am
In my assessment, the number one issue for dating sites is conversion! How do you convert a free user to a paying member? Look at the numbers - they tell the story. We’re leaving 38 million people a month on the table. If you are a third party provider to the industry and cannot answer this question with your product or service, you might as well hang it up now.
MarkusNo Gravatar 03.25.05 at 3:25 pm
I think most dating sites are going to have to start worrying if they can make it another year. I think all these experts that are claiming online dating is slowing etc, don’t know what they are talking about.

If you look in the plentyoffish forums most members use yahoo, match and myspace for dating. Basically paid services are flatlining and about to go into decline and free services such as myspace hi5 etc are skyrocketing. In the last 5 years hardware has really advanced, and costs have fallen so low that nearly anyone can create a dating site that serves millions for under $10 grand/month.

Dating is about to become a commodity with very little to no margin, sites like eharmony which are based on premium “relationship” services are the ones that will make the money in the end…

Dave EvansNo Gravatar 03.25.05 at 3:37 pm
Margins are down at some sites to $15. Free sites will always be there, but they cannot possible provide the next generation of advanced services that the large dating sites will be rolling out. There may be 800 dating sites, but it’s the top 10 that matter, and we can’t even decide what they are? Myspace and dating? Not likely, at least for the over 30 crowd. visitors might be skyrocketing for services like MySpace, but how long will that last? 7th most busy site last month, how high can they go?
Nick MNo Gravatar 03.25.05 at 5:37 pm
In my estimation, it seems that online free and paid dating sites are here to stay. I can see the industry refining itself and of course, like everything else, consolidating. But, I’d like to point out the differences people forget between many paid (not all) sites and the free ones… Advertisements!

The free sites make money by selling something - advertising, mailing lists, Email marketing, whatever. Often, paid sites (or paid areas of sites) will not subject the user to all those ads. Of course, this isn’t true of every site - but many.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post: Industry Job openings

Next post: Job opening: Enpocket